Danfoss on F-gas regulation

F-Gas regulation [EU]

The F-gas regulation was implemented at January 1, 2015. The regulation put in place an HFC phase-down from 2015 to 2030 by means of a quota system and sectorial bans on high GWP refrigerants. 

Read more Read less

Regulatory changes and the derived implications for the RACHP Industry are constantly increasing. The main driver for those changes are environmental concerns (health), resource efficiency and mitigation of climate change. The EU F-gas regulation is considered a front runner, preceding the Kigali Amendment to the Montreal Protocol and going beyond the latter. The legal text as of November 2023 still needs final polishing and it is recommended to access detailed information in the official text.

Figure 1; The phase down the EU and in the US in percentage of baseline

The review of the EU F-Gas regulation:

The first EU F-gas regulation came into force in 2006 with a focus on containment and service. In 2015 the second version came into force, introducing the phase down of high GWP hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) refrigerants. In October 2023 the third version was finally agreed. The latter is an extremely ambitious regulation with a long-term full phase out of F-gases.
The EU and the US phase down are illustrated in Figure 1 where the 2015 F-gas regulation is shown in comparison with the new 2023 agreed phase down. From 2025 the quota is reduced significantly compared to the previous phase-down and from 2030 the available amount of F-gases even for service is challenged.
The quota allocation mechanism has in principle not changed but the previously exempted Metered Dose Inhalers (MDI’s) will be included in the quota as of 2025. Specific sub-quota allocations are made for MDI’s and the available amount for the RACHP industry is consequently reduced with a significant percentage which still has to be exactly specified. The allocation mechanism can be found in the Annex VIII of the Regulation.

Figure 2. The Market prohibitions
Figure 2. The Market prohibitions

The EU equipment bans:

The quota reductions are accompanied by Placing on the market Prohibitions (Bans). Compared to the last revision the amount of bans and level of detail introduced is increasing.
Especially the bans outlined in figure 2 were a big discussion theme during the review period. In the light of the aggressive quota reductions the long-term consequence of having an application specific GWP ban is limited due to the pressure on availability of refrigerants via the phase-down steps (measured in CO₂-equivalents, i.e. GWP multiplied by metric quantity, resulting in highest pressure on higher GWP refrigerants) . However, it sends a clear signal to market on where to focus development efforts.

Export ban: From 2025 the F-gas regulation introduces an export ban for RACHP systems intended for the use of refrigerants with a GWP ≥ 1000 provided that these systems cannot be placed on the EU market.
This means that the date of the bans will set the date for the potential export limitations. This restriction is new, there is no experience with it, and it must still be verified if e.g. units designed for dual refrigerant use like R454B / R410A can count as a unit for the lowest GWP value. The intention of the EU is to address concerns about dumping of equipment, which is obsolete in Europe, into developing countries’ markets.

Heat Pumps:

The EU ambitions on decarbonizing the heating sector imply a massive rollout of heat pumps to phase-out fossil fuel-based heating. The market for heat pumps is already in acceleration mode and there have been valid concerns regarding the availability of F-gases, especially for some of the technologies. This has led to a yearly assessment and a possible extra - but very limited – quota for the years 2025-2029. The concern is particularly related to split systems <12 kW which will also be subject to a GWP limit of 150 from 2027. This can become a serious problem as raised by many industry associations. Small split systems have generally moved to the high pressure refrigerant R32 and a high pressure low GWP version is not available today.

Further, the level of flammability of A3 refrigerants such as hydrocarbons, leads to liability concerns of OEMs. On the other hand, some important applications like small (<12 kW) A/W monoblock heat pumps will have GWP limits of 150 from 2027 and a full F-gas ban from 2032. However, many of those units are today already using R290 so it is not expected to become a major problem.

Figure 3 ; The US phase down
Figure 3 ; The US phase down

Service bans:

Service bans have been strengthened. As of 2025, also small refrigeration systems will no longer be allowed to use virgin refrigerant with a GWP >2500. This will target old systems still relying on R404A. From 2032 the limit will be further decreased to a GWP 750. Service and maintenance of AC and HP equipment will likewise be restricted to a GWP level of 2500 from 2026. It is important to notice that reclaimed and recycled refrigerant can still be used.

FAQ's

To our best knowledge, it will be published at the beginning of 2024.

The Export ban is applicable to regions beyond the EU 27.

Typically, the UK aligns with EU 27 regulations, but we must await the final outcome to confirm.

The review will take the form of a report primarily focusing on the comprehensive evaluation of the full F-gas bans in split A/A AC and HP systems (2032). Additionally, the Export ban will undergo evaluation. While potential changes to the bans may be considered through delegated acts, it's important to note that this will not be a full review.

No, the GWP is derived from the 4th Assessment Report.

Natural refrigerants offer a solution, albeit with inherent limitations. It's worth noting that certain F-gases are not PFAS, and we must exercise patience as we await the conclusive results of the REACH PFAS evaluation to fully understand future possibilities.

From 2030 the GWP limit for all stationary refrigeration systems, except chillers, is 150. Until 2030 the GWP limit is 2500.

From 2030 there will be a GWP limit of 150.

Referring to systems with ambient temperatures exceeding 65°C, if safety requirements restrict the use of high-GWP refrigerants, the limit is set at 750 (Annex IV (8). There is a need for clarification regarding the practices associated with utilizing this exemption.

Until 2030, systems with a temperature below -50°C are not subject to any GWP limit. Starting in 2030, the GWP limit will be set at 150.

No, there won't be a ban for refrigeration systems. However, for small chillers and monoblock AC/HP systems up to 12 kW, there will be a complete F-gas ban starting in 2032. Additionally, for split AC/HP systems up to 12 kW, a full F-gas ban will be implemented from 2035.

That has not yet been decided

More about refrigerants